Looking for a 1725 Holbay Engine.
- djnippa
- Posts: 142
- Joined: Sat Aug 04, 2012 6:41 pm
- Location: Streatham, London
Re: Looking for a 1725 Holbay Engine.
Anybody know roughly know how much a 1725 Engine with ancillaries and Gearbox, would weigh?
-
rootesmadnick
- Posts: 272
- Joined: Fri Feb 01, 2008 7:42 pm
- Location: lumbering in a humber somwhere !!
- Contact:
Re: Looking for a 1725 Holbay Engine.
a lot.. the gearboxes are huge on their own... I could move a bottom end by my own without the head and flywheel on but only just so it has to be getting on for 200kgs with the gearbox bolted on...
I fix things!!
- djnippa
- Posts: 142
- Joined: Sat Aug 04, 2012 6:41 pm
- Location: Streatham, London
Re: Looking for a 1725 Holbay Engine.
Does anyone know if the gearbox from a Hillman Hunter GLS / Sunbeam Rapier Fastback will drop straight into a Humber Sceptre MK2 ?
Or would the prop-shaft be the wrong length?
Or would the prop-shaft be the wrong length?
-
thowman
- Posts: 79
- Joined: Mon May 24, 2010 9:31 pm
Re: Looking for a 1725 Holbay Engine.
Short answer - Nodjnippa wrote:Does anyone know if the gearbox from a Hillman Hunter GLS / Sunbeam Rapier Fastback will drop straight into a Humber Sceptre MK2 ?
Or would the prop-shaft be the wrong length?
Long answer - the bell housing and input shaft on an arrows box are longer, and the engine in the arrows is slightly tilted from the vertical. You can convert them, but you would need to dismantle and rebuild the gearbox.
- djnippa
- Posts: 142
- Joined: Sat Aug 04, 2012 6:41 pm
- Location: Streatham, London
Re: Looking for a 1725 Holbay Engine.
Eek. That sounds like I'd have to buy the Gearbox from a Fastback/ Hunter GLS, if I'm still going to get a Holbay.
I've bid on 3 Holbay engines so far, the best one (fuel injection fitted, and 90% reconditioned) I went up to £1250, and still didn't win.
I've been to Cornwall and Manchester, to look at a couple, an still no joy (They weren't proper Holbays)
So I've decided to forget looking for one, and recondition my original engine and gearbox.
I'm thinking get the cam done to racing specs by Kent Cams.
Get it rebored to 1970cc
Add some Flat-head pistons for extra compression.
I may still have to buy a Holbay Head, as I'm unsure what the kidney shaped inlet vales actually add to HP. Does anyone know what difference this make?
I'll also be putting on the Twin Webers DC40, and getting a four into one down-pipe by Vortex.
So with all that I should be able to reach the 110-120 BHP.
Does any one else no if I would need to do anything extra to it?
I think it will be good to keep the Original matching numbers Engine & Gearbox, if i decide to sell it in the future.
I've bid on 3 Holbay engines so far, the best one (fuel injection fitted, and 90% reconditioned) I went up to £1250, and still didn't win.
I've been to Cornwall and Manchester, to look at a couple, an still no joy (They weren't proper Holbays)
So I've decided to forget looking for one, and recondition my original engine and gearbox.
I'm thinking get the cam done to racing specs by Kent Cams.
Get it rebored to 1970cc
Add some Flat-head pistons for extra compression.
I may still have to buy a Holbay Head, as I'm unsure what the kidney shaped inlet vales actually add to HP. Does anyone know what difference this make?
I'll also be putting on the Twin Webers DC40, and getting a four into one down-pipe by Vortex.
So with all that I should be able to reach the 110-120 BHP.
Does any one else no if I would need to do anything extra to it?
I think it will be good to keep the Original matching numbers Engine & Gearbox, if i decide to sell it in the future.
-
turbinecol
- Posts: 125
- Joined: Wed May 02, 2007 4:14 pm
- Location: South East England
Re: Looking for a 1725 Holbay Engine.
I was also looking at that fuel injected engine - it had come out of a Ginetta I think, so the upright intake manifold would have suited a Mk2 Sceptre. The problems were the E128 'rally' cam and lightened flywheel could have made it a very lumpy proposition at idle - just an unknown there. Also, restoring to carb power was going to be tricky as lots of missing bits and pieces - the biggest headache was with the E128 cam and enlarged chambers fitted over a standard holbay - you'd need to find and modify a standard intake manifold to suit the arrangement, and who knows if the standard Holbay distributor would work - so I decided it was all getting too tricky.
That engine was always going to go for silly money - the trouble is you're competing with Sunbeam Alpine boys at that level, and it seems they have vastly more money than us....
The whole idea of the holbay head is to improve fluid flow to get better power, but with all the head pockets opened up the arrangement needs flat top pistons to raise the CR back to normal. So it also follows if you put flat top pistons on, you will need to open up the kidney chambers to bring the CR back down to normal to prevent detonation, and although you can the kidney modifications to the standard head I think you then run into limitations on the valve sizes - so do a bit more reseach on that.
My best advice is joint the Sunbeam rapier owners club forum (still free of course)- some very knowledgeable guys on there (look out for a guy called '1922', lots of holbay knowledge), and there is another good lad with a Grey Rapier who is adding a Holbay head and twin 40's to his standard 1725, but I think he is having running problems at the moment (possibly due to the distrubutor curve not matched, the intake not matched, airleaks etc. Work in progress but he will figure it out.....)
That engine was always going to go for silly money - the trouble is you're competing with Sunbeam Alpine boys at that level, and it seems they have vastly more money than us....
The whole idea of the holbay head is to improve fluid flow to get better power, but with all the head pockets opened up the arrangement needs flat top pistons to raise the CR back to normal. So it also follows if you put flat top pistons on, you will need to open up the kidney chambers to bring the CR back down to normal to prevent detonation, and although you can the kidney modifications to the standard head I think you then run into limitations on the valve sizes - so do a bit more reseach on that.
My best advice is joint the Sunbeam rapier owners club forum (still free of course)- some very knowledgeable guys on there (look out for a guy called '1922', lots of holbay knowledge), and there is another good lad with a Grey Rapier who is adding a Holbay head and twin 40's to his standard 1725, but I think he is having running problems at the moment (possibly due to the distrubutor curve not matched, the intake not matched, airleaks etc. Work in progress but he will figure it out.....)
- djnippa
- Posts: 142
- Joined: Sat Aug 04, 2012 6:41 pm
- Location: Streatham, London
Re: Looking for a 1725 Holbay Engine.
Yes it was out of a Ginetta. I am actually very relieved I didn't win it.
It would have needed way too much work, with ECU's and adding a stronger fuel pump in the boot.
I would've also had to buy the gearbox he had for sale as well.
I only know a small amount, and the electroncs side is way beyond my knowledge.
That's a great tip for the Sunbeam Rapier club.
I'm not a member, but I've read the two sections before, and where I gleaned most of my knowledge on Holbay part numbers and specs from.
I'll read it again, now I'm planning on a different direction.
It would have needed way too much work, with ECU's and adding a stronger fuel pump in the boot.
I would've also had to buy the gearbox he had for sale as well.
I only know a small amount, and the electroncs side is way beyond my knowledge.
That's a great tip for the Sunbeam Rapier club.
I'm not a member, but I've read the two sections before, and where I gleaned most of my knowledge on Holbay part numbers and specs from.
I'll read it again, now I'm planning on a different direction.
-
turbinecol
- Posts: 125
- Joined: Wed May 02, 2007 4:14 pm
- Location: South East England
Re: Looking for a 1725 Holbay Engine.
Excellent.
Yes, I know opinions differ on how much to modify cars, but by the time you start adding fuel injection you're getting to the point where you are better off just getting a more modern lump, and then you have to start getting into a never ending cycle of upgrading. Gets expensive that and needs quite a bit of experimentation to get the best out of things..
Yes, I know opinions differ on how much to modify cars, but by the time you start adding fuel injection you're getting to the point where you are better off just getting a more modern lump, and then you have to start getting into a never ending cycle of upgrading. Gets expensive that and needs quite a bit of experimentation to get the best out of things..
-
hoppo
- Posts: 90
- Joined: Thu Dec 06, 2012 12:17 pm
Re: Looking for a 1725 Holbay Engine.
If your still looking one on ebay now 4th may 18.00 hrs complete overhauled (it says) less carbs 6 days to run 99p
- djnippa
- Posts: 142
- Joined: Sat Aug 04, 2012 6:41 pm
- Location: Streatham, London
Re: Looking for a 1725 Holbay Engine.
I'm NOT looking anymore.
After a year of searching, and several long disappointing journey's, and being outbid on Ebay every time.... even after a £1260 bid for a custom fuel injected one.
I have decided to keep the ORIGINAL engine & gearbox, and get them totally reconditioned - with a few extra modifications.
ENGINE:
1. Flat top pistons (already have)
2. Bigger bores.
3. Racing Cam shaft + followers.
4. Twin Webers (already have)
5. Hardened bigger inlet valves.
6. Custom 4 into 1 stainless steel exhaust manifold.
7. Fast road distributor with electronic ignition (already have a polished one)
8. All other parts replaced by new ones where possible.
9. Full balancing.
10. New Water Pump (already have)
TOTAL COST: £1300 + exhaust (when I can afford it)
Should increase power to around 115-120 bhp.
plus the chromed timing cover, chromed engine inspection plate, polished HOLBAY rocker cover, that I already have.
GEARBOX:
A full reconditioning.
I'm not sure what else I can do with the gearbox. Suggestions appreciated.
May be I'll ask the guys who are going to recondition it.
TOTAL COST: £300-£400 + parts.
What do you think?
After a year of searching, and several long disappointing journey's, and being outbid on Ebay every time.... even after a £1260 bid for a custom fuel injected one.
I have decided to keep the ORIGINAL engine & gearbox, and get them totally reconditioned - with a few extra modifications.
ENGINE:
1. Flat top pistons (already have)
2. Bigger bores.
3. Racing Cam shaft + followers.
4. Twin Webers (already have)
5. Hardened bigger inlet valves.
6. Custom 4 into 1 stainless steel exhaust manifold.
7. Fast road distributor with electronic ignition (already have a polished one)
8. All other parts replaced by new ones where possible.
9. Full balancing.
10. New Water Pump (already have)
TOTAL COST: £1300 + exhaust (when I can afford it)
Should increase power to around 115-120 bhp.
plus the chromed timing cover, chromed engine inspection plate, polished HOLBAY rocker cover, that I already have.
GEARBOX:
A full reconditioning.
I'm not sure what else I can do with the gearbox. Suggestions appreciated.
May be I'll ask the guys who are going to recondition it.
TOTAL COST: £300-£400 + parts.
What do you think?
Last edited by djnippa on Wed May 08, 2013 11:53 pm, edited 1 time in total.
-
gijoe
- Posts: 8
- Joined: Sat Mar 23, 2013 6:03 pm
Re: Looking for a 1725 Holbay Engine.
Hello
thanks for the reply well this give me an idea
on where to start my price when/if I list/sell my
Holbay engine w/gearbox, I've looked everywhere for
the past 6 months but I never could found one (Holbay engine)
I think I will set this engine on a engine test/run in stand to be able to show
that this is a perfect running engine.
thanks again
thanks for the reply well this give me an idea
on where to start my price when/if I list/sell my
Holbay engine w/gearbox, I've looked everywhere for
the past 6 months but I never could found one (Holbay engine)
I think I will set this engine on a engine test/run in stand to be able to show
that this is a perfect running engine.
thanks again
- djnippa
- Posts: 142
- Joined: Sat Aug 04, 2012 6:41 pm
- Location: Streatham, London
Re: Looking for a 1725 Holbay Engine.
The engines I looked at and bid on were roughly as follows:-
£1282 - Ebay
Engine with all ancillaries and twin Webers. Fuel injected custom full mapping. Needed ECU (would've cost £600). No exhaust manifold. This was a very special engine.
£760 - Ebay
Working Engine. Twin carbs. Full mapping. Not a true Holbay, but slightly better as fast road cam was made by Kent Cams (£95)
£250
Engine. No carbs. No flywheel. Not a real Holbay as the Cam was different, and no flat-top pistons.
£150
Engine. stripped into bits and odd ends everywhere.
£1282 - Ebay
Engine with all ancillaries and twin Webers. Fuel injected custom full mapping. Needed ECU (would've cost £600). No exhaust manifold. This was a very special engine.
£760 - Ebay
Working Engine. Twin carbs. Full mapping. Not a true Holbay, but slightly better as fast road cam was made by Kent Cams (£95)
£250
Engine. No carbs. No flywheel. Not a real Holbay as the Cam was different, and no flat-top pistons.
£150
Engine. stripped into bits and odd ends everywhere.
-
gijoe
- Posts: 8
- Joined: Sat Mar 23, 2013 6:03 pm
Re: Looking for a 1725 Holbay Engine.
Hello
could i ask if you ever found that Holbay engine you were looking for?
thank you
could i ask if you ever found that Holbay engine you were looking for?
thank you
djnippa wrote:I know they are few and far between,
but I'm looking for a 1725 Holbay Engine H120.
Any condition considered, providing it's all there.
My current standard engine needs the thrust bearing replacing, and hardened valve seats dropped in to take unleaded petrol.
So I figured I might as well work on another more powerful engine, that I can finally put my Twin Webers DC40's on.
Any leads appreciated.
- djnippa
- Posts: 142
- Joined: Sat Aug 04, 2012 6:41 pm
- Location: Streatham, London
Re: Looking for a 1725 Holbay Engine.
Please read my previous two comments.
-
billyradcliffe
- Posts: 1
- Joined: Thu May 30, 2013 7:06 am
- Location: Bexleyheath